Best Kitchen Compost Bins for Your Countertop

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

The two best-selling kitchen compost pails on Amazon fight smell in opposite ways. The Utopia lets air out through a charcoal filter in the lid. The OXO keeps air in behind a closed lid with no filter at all. Both work. Which one suits your kitchen depends on how often you empty it, not on what it costs.

That choice, filter or sealed lid, is what separates the best kitchen compost bin for one household from the wrong one for the next. Our six picks cover both camps, from a 1-gallon caddy that hangs on a cabinet door to a 1.75-gallon pail for a family that cooks every night. If you would rather not keep scraps on the counter at all, an electric composter dries them down in hours and skips the pail entirely.

Quick answer: For most kitchens, get the Epica. On a tight budget, get the Utopia. Want the biggest pail and the easiest one to wash? Get the OXO Easy-Clean.

Quick Comparison: Our Top Picks at a Glance

Read the last column first. Three pails vent through charcoal, two seal shut, and one hangs on a door. That difference decides how often you walk scraps outside.

Kitchen compost bins are often discounted during fall sales and Black Friday. Prices change daily, so check the current price on Amazon before you buy.

Model Rating Best For Size and Odor Control Link
EPICA Kitchen Compost Bin 4.6★ (21,011) Best Overall 1.3 gal, steel, charcoal filter Check Price on Amazon →
Utopia Kitchen Compost Bin 4.5★ (20,132) Best Value 1.3 gal, steel, charcoal filter Check Price on Amazon →
OXO Good Grips Easy-Clean 4.6★ (18,100) Easiest to Clean 1.75 gal, plastic, sealed lid, no filter Check Price on Amazon →
RED FACTOR Premium Compost Bin 4.8★ (5,926) Highest Rated 1.3 gal, steel, dual charcoal filter Check Price on Amazon →
Blue Ginkgo Kitchen Compost Bin 4.6★ (4,837) Best Filter-Free 1.32 gal, plastic, airtight, no filter Check Price on Amazon →
Joseph Joseph Compo 4.6★ (5,174) Best for Small Kitchens 1 gal, plastic, mounts on a cabinet door Check Price on Amazon →

Charcoal Filter or Sealed Lid: How Kitchen Compost Bins Control Odor

“Odor control” is really two different designs, and they behave differently on day three.

Charcoal filter lids. The Epica, Utopia and RED FACTOR have small vents in the lid with a pad of activated charcoal behind them. Moisture escapes, and the charcoal catches the smell on its way out. Scraps stay a little drier, so they grow less mold between emptyings. The trade-off is upkeep: the filter loads up and needs replacing every few months. In warm weather, fruit flies can also find their way to the vents if scraps sit too long.

Sealed or airtight lids. The OXO, Blue Ginkgo and Joseph Joseph skip the filter. There is nothing to buy again, and with the lid closed, flies have no way in. The smell stays inside too, which means it comes out in one burst when you lift the lid. Wet scraps in a closed pail turn slimy faster, so these bins reward emptying every 2 to 3 days.

Steel or plastic. Stainless steel looks better on the counter and does not stain. Plastic is lighter, often goes in the dishwasher, and has no rim that can rust or crack.

Size. As a working guideline, 1 to 1.3 gallons suits one or two people who empty twice a week. Families, or anyone who empties once a week, should look at 1.75 gallons or more.

One bin we left out of the main list: the simplehuman Compost Caddy docks onto simplehuman trash cans, and it is worth a look mainly if you already own one. At about 1.06 gallons, it is small for the money.

The Best Kitchen Compost Bins

Six pails, each matched to a kind of kitchen. The first four are the category’s bestsellers and its top-rated pail. The last two solve specific problems: no filters to replace, and no counter space to spare.

EPICA Kitchen Compost Bin: Best Overall

Best Overall

EPICA 1.3 gallon stainless steel kitchen compost bin with charcoal filter lid

4.6★ (21,011) · 1.3 gal · Stainless steel · Charcoal filter lid

The Epica has the largest owner base of any pail in this roundup, and the three things those owners praise most are quality, looks and the absence of smell. That last one is why the Epica is our pick for most kitchens.

The body is a single piece of molded stainless steel. The lid takes a replaceable charcoal filter. One owner describes a double filter setup, a 6.7-inch round pad plus a 5-inch square one, and another notes the lid accepts both shapes, so replacements are easy to find.

1.3 gal capacity One-piece stainless steel Replaceable charcoal filter 7.2 x 7.2 x 11 in

What we like:

  • The biggest owner base in the category, with a 4.6★ average from 21,011 ratings
  • One-piece molded stainless steel body
  • Lid takes both round and square charcoal filters, so refills are easy to source
  • Looks good enough to leave out: appearance is the second most praised aspect
  • A 7.2-inch square footprint that fits beside the sink or under it

What to watch for:

  • In summer, fruit flies can find the lid vents. Empty it every 2 to 3 days and keep the filter dry.
  • The listing does not call it dishwasher safe. Wash it by hand; the smooth steel rinses clean in a minute.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “I purchased this last year in November and have had it now for over half a year. I love this compost bin. It works really well and is great at preventing fruit flies and smells in the kitchen.”: Verified Amazon purchase, more than 6 months of ownership

Our verdict: The best kitchen compost bin for most households. It keeps smells in, looks right on the counter, and has the longest owner track record of any pail here.

Check Price on Amazon →

Utopia Kitchen Compost Bin: Best Value

Best Value

Utopia Kitchen 1.3 gallon stainless steel compost bin with handle and filter lid

4.5★ (20,132) · 1.3 gal · Stainless steel · 2 lb

No kitchen compost bin sells more on Amazon. The Utopia sits at number one in the indoor compost bin category, with more than 3,000 bought every month, and it is the lowest-cost stainless steel pail on this list. The design matches the Epica: steel pail, carry handle, charcoal filter lid.

Owners keep coming back to three points: it is easy to clean, it holds odors well, and it is good value. At 7.2 inches wide and 11.2 inches tall, it is slim enough to tuck under a sink as well as sit on the counter.

1.3 gal (4.9 L) Stainless steel Charcoal filter in lid 7.2 in wide, 11.2 in high 2 lb

What we like:

  • The lowest-cost stainless pail in this roundup
  • Amazon’s number one seller in indoor compost bins, with 20,132 ratings behind it
  • Light at 2 lb, easy to carry out to the bin by the handle
  • Slim enough for the cabinet under the sink

What to watch for:

  • The raised ridge near the top is the thinnest part of the steel. Carry it by the handle, set it down gently, and do not press the lid hard onto the rim.
  • The filter needs swapping every few months. Keep a spare pack in the drawer.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “It is the perfect size for under the sink. The lid fits well, and the filters are terrific for keeping odors and fruit flies at bay.”: Verified Amazon purchase

Our verdict: The best value in kitchen compost bins. If you want stainless steel and a charcoal filter for less, the Utopia does the job that made it the category bestseller.

Check Price on Amazon →

OXO Good Grips Easy-Clean Compost Bin: Easiest to Clean

Easiest to Clean

OXO Good Grips Easy-Clean 1.75 gallon plastic compost bin with stay-open lid

4.6★ (18,100) · 1.75 gal · Plastic · No filter

The OXO is the biggest pail among the bestsellers, and the one built around cleaning. The inside is smooth plastic, and the lid hides the edge of a bag liner so nothing shows from the counter. It is Amazon’s number two seller in the category.

The lid stays open while you scrape a cutting board in, then closes softly. There is no filter to buy. Owners call it easy to clean, easy to use, and the right size for two people.

1.75 gal (6.6 L) Smooth plastic interior Stay-open, soft-close lid No filter to replace Hides the bag edge

What we like:

  • The largest capacity of the top sellers, enough for a family or a weekend of cooking
  • Smooth plastic interior that wipes clean quickly
  • Lid stays open hands-free while you fill it
  • No filters to replace, ever

What to watch for:

  • With no filter, smell builds up after a few days and comes out when you open it. Empty it sooner, or line it with a compostable bag.
  • Abrasive scrubbers mark the plastic. A soft sponge keeps the inside smooth.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “We’ve never had any issues with smells and it’s very easy to clean. … It seems durable- isn’t showing any wear after 7 months of daily use.”: Verified Amazon purchase, 7 months of ownership

Our verdict: The easiest kitchen compost bin to keep clean, and the best size for families. If washing the pail is the chore you dread, start here.

Check Price on Amazon →

📝 Editor’s note: In summer, kitchen scraps that sit more than three days start to ferment, and fermenting fruit is what draws fruit flies, whatever lid is on top. That is why a pail that holds two to three days of your household’s scraps works better than a bigger one you empty once a week. One habit from our own composting helps more than any lid: keep a small bag of shredded leaves or torn newspaper next to the pail and drop a handful on top of wet scraps. It soaks up the liquid and cuts the smell before it starts.

RED FACTOR Premium Compost Bin: Highest Rated

Highest Rated

RED FACTOR Premium 1.3 gallon stainless steel compost bin with dome lid

4.8★ (5,926) · 1.3 gal · Stainless steel · Dual charcoal filter

At 4.8★, the RED FACTOR holds the highest rating of any bin we compared, with nearly 6,000 ratings behind it. It suits kitchens where the pail sits in plain view. It comes in stainless steel, copper and other finishes, and owners single out the finish for staying free of scratches and cracks.

The dome lid carries two charcoal filters instead of one, and spare filters come in the box. Owners say it keeps working through heat waves, which is when most pails start to smell.

1.3 gal (5 L) Stainless steel, several finishes Dome lid, dual charcoal filter Spare filters included

What we like:

  • The highest rating in this roundup, 4.8★ from 5,926 ratings
  • Two charcoal filters in the lid for extra odor control
  • Spare filters included, so your first replacement is already on hand
  • A choice of finishes to match your kitchen, praised for resisting scratches

What to watch for:

  • The lid sits on top rather than locking. Press it down firmly after every use.
  • In warm months, flies and ants can find the filter vents. Empty it every 2 to 3 days in summer.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “We’ve been using it all summer. It is the perfect size for our countertop. It keeps our food scraps from smelling or attracting flies. It is SO easy to clean.”: Verified Amazon purchase

Our verdict: The top-rated kitchen compost bin, and the best-looking one for an open counter. Two filters and a spare set make it the steel pail that asks the least of you.

Check Price on Amazon →

Blue Ginkgo Kitchen Compost Bin: Best Filter-Free

Best Filter-Free

Blue Ginkgo 5 liter airtight kitchen compost bin with removable colander

4.6★ (4,837) · 1.32 gal · Polypropylene · Airtight, no filter

The Blue Ginkgo is the only strong pick that is both filter-free and dishwasher safe. It is made in South Korea from polypropylene, with an airtight lid that seals the smell inside, so there is nothing to replace every few months.

Inside sits a removable colander. Wet scraps drain through it instead of sitting in their own liquid, and you lift the whole basket out to empty it.

1.32 gal (5 L) Polypropylene, made in South Korea Airtight lid, no filter Removable colander Dishwasher safe

What we like:

  • No filter to buy or replace, ever
  • Airtight seal keeps fruit flies out when the lid is closed
  • Dishwasher safe, so cleaning takes no effort
  • Removable colander keeps scraps out of their own juice

What to watch for:

  • Sized for one or two people. Bigger households should plan to empty it every 2 to 3 days.
  • The tight lid can take two hands at first. That snug fit is what keeps the smell inside.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “We empty the compost bin every few days. But because it’s air tight, there’s no smell, no fruit flies – no problems at all. We don’t have to hassle with filters.”: Verified Amazon purchase

Our verdict: The best filter-free kitchen compost bin. If you empty every few days and never want to buy a filter again, this one goes straight into the dishwasher.

Check Price on Amazon →

Joseph Joseph Compo Compost Caddy: Best for Small Kitchens

Best for Small Kitchens

Joseph Joseph Compo 1 gallon wall-mountable compost caddy for a cabinet door

4.6★ (5,174) · 1 gal · Polypropylene · Door-mountable

In a studio or a galley kitchen, the counter is the last place you want a compost pail. The Joseph Joseph Compo mounts on the inside of a cabinet door, so it sits at hand while you cook and disappears when you close the cupboard.

At 1 gallon, it is the smallest bin on this list, and that suits a one- or two-person kitchen that empties often. Owners call it compact, easy to empty and good at holding odors. It goes in the dishwasher, and it carries the same 4.6★ rating as the Epica.

1 gal (4 L) Polypropylene Cabinet door or counter Dishwasher safe

What we like:

  • Mounts on a cabinet door and takes no counter space
  • Also stands on the counter, so it works in any kitchen
  • Dishwasher safe
  • The lowest-cost pick in this roundup with a 4.6★ rating

What to watch for:

  • The lid closes but does not latch. Press it shut each time, and keep it inside the cabinet where it stays out of the way.
  • The included screws are small. On thick doors, use your own longer screws.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “It’s so great to have it out of the way instead on the counter all the time, and it’s very accessible in the cabinet.”: Verified Amazon purchase

Our verdict: The best kitchen compost bin for small kitchens and apartments. It hides inside a cabinet door, washes in the dishwasher, and keeps the counter clear.

Check Price on Amazon →

Kitchen Compost Bins We Researched but Don’t Recommend

Gleynest 2.6-Gallon Hanging Compost Bin: The Gleynest sells more than 1,000 units a month, and its idea is a good one: a large hanging bin with a lid that opens two ways. The build falls short. Its share of 1-star ratings is the highest of any bin we compared, and Amazon’s own summary of owner feedback describes it as flimsy, with a lid that does not close properly. Owners describe thin plastic, a handle that came off within weeks, and lid guides that break. One owner measured about 1.8 gallons of usable space, well short of the 2.6 on the label. We’re not recommending the Gleynest. For a bin that hangs on a cabinet door, the Joseph Joseph Compo is the better buy.

Which Kitchen Compost Bin Is Right for You?

🌱 Most kitchens, and you want it to look good on the counter?
The EPICA Kitchen Compost Bin pairs one-piece stainless steel with a charcoal filter lid and the deepest owner record in the category.
💰 Want stainless steel for the lowest cost?
The Utopia Kitchen Compost Bin is the category bestseller, with the same filter lid design and a slim body that fits under the sink.
🍽️ Family meals or big weekend cooking, and easy washing?
The OXO Good Grips Easy-Clean holds 1.75 gallons and has a smooth interior that wipes clean.
🏢 Apartment or small kitchen with no counter space?
The Joseph Joseph Compo mounts inside a cabinet door and goes in the dishwasher.

How to Keep a Countertop Compost Bin From Smelling

A countertop compost bin that doesn’t smell is mostly about habits. These work with any pail on this list.

Empty it on a schedule. Every 2 to 3 days in warm weather, about once a week in winter.

Line it, and add browns. A compostable bag or a single sheet of newspaper keeps liquid off the bottom of the pail. A handful of dry browns on top, such as shredded leaves, torn cardboard or newspaper, soaks up moisture and buffers the smell.

Keep the filter dry. A wet charcoal filter stops working. Wipe the underside of the lid when you empty the pail, and replace the filter once the smell comes back.

Freeze the worst of it. Very wet or strong-smelling scraps, like melon rinds or onion skins in July, can go in a bag in the freezer until the next trip outside. Meat does not belong in a home compost pile anyway.

Rinse after every emptying. Warm water and a drop of dish soap is enough. For a lingering smell, add a splash of white vinegar and let it sit for a few minutes before rinsing.

Stop fruit flies early. Close the lid every time, empty the pail sooner in summer, and never leave fruit peels sitting uncovered on top.

Have somewhere to take it. The pail is only a holding spot. A sealed tumbler outside the back door turns those scraps into compost and keeps them away from pests; our picks for the best compost tumblers cover sizes for every yard.

Bags and Filters for Your Kitchen Compost Bin

Two refills keep a kitchen pail running: compostable liners for the sealed bins, and charcoal filters for the vented ones.

RefillRatingFitsLink
UNNI 2.6-gallon compostable bags (100 per box)4.6★ (30,774)OXO Easy-Clean 1.75 gal; the lid hides the bag edgeCheck Price on Amazon →
6.7-inch round charcoal filters4.5★ (4,781)Epica lid (round 6.7 in filter)Check Price on Amazon →

For smaller 1 to 1.3-gallon pails, SUPERBIO’s 1.6-gallon compostable bags (50 per box) are the number two seller in the same category.

FAQ

What is the best size for a kitchen compost bin?

For one or two people who empty the pail twice a week, 1 to 1.3 gallons is enough. The Epica, Utopia, RED FACTOR and Blue Ginkgo all sit in that range. Families, heavy cooks, or anyone who empties once a week should look at 1.75 gallons or more, like the OXO Easy-Clean.

Do kitchen compost bins need a charcoal filter?

No. A charcoal filter lets moisture out and traps the smell, which keeps scraps drier. A sealed lid without a filter, like the OXO or Blue Ginkgo, keeps both smell and flies inside and works just as well if you empty it every 2 to 3 days.

How often should you empty a countertop compost bin?

Every 2 to 3 days in summer, and about once a week in cool months. Heat speeds up fermentation, and fermenting scraps are what smell and draw fruit flies.

How do you keep fruit flies out of a kitchen compost bin?

Keep the lid closed every time, empty the pail sooner in warm weather, and rinse it after each emptying so no residue is left behind. Cover fresh scraps with a handful of shredded leaves or newspaper, and never leave fruit peels uncovered on top.

Is a stainless steel or plastic compost bin better?

Neither wins outright. Stainless steel looks better on the counter, does not stain and does not hold smells. Plastic is lighter, often dishwasher safe, and has no rim that can rust or crack.

Do you need bags in a kitchen compost bin?

No, but they make emptying cleaner. A compostable bag keeps liquid off the bottom of the pail and lets you lift everything out in one go. Look for bags certified compostable by BPI, and check what your city collection accepts first: some programs take compostable bags, some do not.

How often should you change the charcoal filter?

When you start to smell the pail again. For most kitchens, that works out to every few months. Owners who rinse the filter and let it dry fully between uses report that it lasts longer.

What can you put in a kitchen compost bin?

Fruit and vegetable scraps, coffee grounds and paper filters, tea bags without plastic, and crushed eggshells all go in. Keep meat, dairy and oily food out if the scraps are headed for a home compost pile, because they smell and attract pests. City collection programs often accept more, so check their rules if your pail goes to the curb.

Free for beginners

Get the Free Composting Starter Kit

5-day email course + printable guide + our top product picks. Everything you need to start composting confidently.

Get Free Access

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.